How to Avoid 50/50 Deadlocks in Business Partnerships
Forming a business partnership often feels like a natural step toward success. You share the responsibilities, risks, and rewards equally, and it may seem logical to split ownership 50/50. However, one of the most common pitfalls of a 50/50 partnership is the risk of a deadlock—a situation where partners cannot agree on a critical decision, leaving the business at a standstill.
In this article, we’ll explore the key ways to prevent and resolve deadlocks in business partnerships, ensuring that your business can keep moving forward. Whether you’re in the early stages of forming a partnership or looking for ways to fix existing issues, these solutions can help.
Why Deadlocks Are Dangerous
A deadlock occurs when two equal partners in a business can’t agree on a major decision, leading to a stalemate. This can be extremely damaging, especially when fast decisions are needed to keep the business running smoothly. Without a way to break the tie, a deadlock can cause:
- Operational Delays: Key decisions about the business—whether about finances, strategy, or management—get delayed.
- Deteriorating Relationships: Ongoing disagreements can damage the trust and communication between partners.
- Financial Loss: A deadlock could mean missed opportunities, stalled projects, or even the dissolution of the business.
- Dissolution: If proper planning wasn’t done ahead of time, your only option may be to dissolve the company.
So, how do you prevent or resolve a 50/50 deadlock before it threatens the business? Here are some of the best options.
1. Set Up a Tie-Breaking Mechanism in the Agreement
When forming a partnership, it’s critical to plan for disagreements ahead of time. This can be done by building a tie-breaking mechanism directly into your partnership or shareholder agreement.
What You Should Ask Your Lawyer: What kind of tie-breaking mechanism fits your business best? Can you trust an external advisor to make key decisions?
2. Use a Buy-Sell Agreement
A buy-sell agreement outlines the process if one partner wants to leave the business or sell their share due to a deadlock. This agreement can include a “deadlock resolution clause”, which sets terms for what happens if partners reach an impasse.
What You Should Ask Your Lawyer: How can a buy-sell agreement protect both parties if a deadlock occurs? Is a shotgun clause the right choice for your partnership?
3. Consider an Advisory Board or Committee
An advisory board or a small committee of trusted business experts can be invaluable when resolving deadlocks. Rather than allowing the business to stall due to disagreements, the board can step in to provide guidance or even make final decisions in certain circumstances.
What You Should Ask Your Lawyer: What responsibilities should you give an advisory board? Should they have final say on specific decisions?
4. Avoid a 50/50 Split in Ownership
While a 50/50 split seems fair, it can create deadlocks easily. One way to prevent this is by adjusting the ownership structure slightly so one partner holds a majority, even if it’s just by a small margin (e.g., 51/49).
What You Should Ask Your Lawyer: Would a 51/49 ownership split cause tension in your partnership? Is a supermajority vote a better way to avoid deadlocks?
5. Mediation or Arbitration
Mediation and arbitration can help partners resolve disputes without going to court. These processes are less formal, faster, and usually less expensive than litigation.
What You Should Ask Your Lawyer: Should mediation or arbitration be included in your partnership agreement? How do you choose the right mediator or arbitrator?
6. Divide Responsibilities
Another strategy is to divide responsibilities based on expertise. For example, one partner might take full control of financial decisions, while the other manages operations. This reduces the need for joint decision-making and can help prevent deadlocks.
What You Should Ask Your Lawyer: How should responsibilities be divided to avoid overlap? Can these divisions be clearly outlined in a legally binding agreement?
7. Escalation Process
An escalation clause in your partnership agreement outlines a formal process to follow if partners cannot agree on a decision. This may include:
- Internal Discussions: A rule requiring both parties to attempt to resolve disputes through formal discussions.
- Mediation: If discussions fail, involve a mediator to help resolve the issue.
- Sale or Buyout: If no agreement is reached, the escalation clause may trigger a sale, buyout, or other formal resolution process.
What You Should Ask Your Lawyer: How should the escalation process be structured? Should there be a time limit on each stage to avoid long delays?
Conclusion
Deadlocks in business partnerships can cause significant disruptions, but the right planning and legal mechanisms can prevent or resolve them effectively. Whether it’s building a clear dispute resolution process, introducing a buy-sell agreement, or using a trusted advisory board, taking proactive steps ensures your business won’t be derailed by disagreements.
Ready to protect your partnership from deadlocks? Contact our legal team today to discuss the best strategies for your specific business situation.
Ready to get started? Let’s talk today.